The purpose of all social sciences is to answer a fundamental question: what is a human being and why do they do what they are doing in society? This question requires to be systematically answered, hence we need a firm understanding of methodology. The purpose of this course is to uncover the conceptual roots and ontological and epistemological assumptions of major methodological schools in social sciences. While surveying the basic assumptions of major schools, the course will uphold a genetic approach, that is, it will comparatively discuss the origins and theoretical foundations of each school.
Rather than preferring one approach over others, the course aims to illustrate the existence of the wide array of methodological approaches in social sciences. Various approaches emanating from different worldviews and ideologies may sometimes appear in tension with one another. The course aims to bring them in dialogue in a comparative perspective by highlighting their strengths and potentials as well as drawbacks and limitations.
As a core curriculum course it will briefly cover particular major methods and their applications. The detailed examination will be offered by each department in line with their own field-specific priorities. The objective of the course is to create an awareness about the intimate link between fundamental ontological and epistemological assumptions of schools of thought and their methodological preferences, and it will encourage students to recognize and reflect upon variations of these links.
The course will provide alternative insights to conventional Western social science methods by highlighting the potential power of the well-established Islamic schools of thought to respond to present questions of social sciences. In this regard, the methods of falsafa, kalām, taṣawwuf and fiqh will be presented along with with a social science and humanities perspective. They will be presented as paradigms, theories and methods that attempt to answer the core question mentioned above.
In short, the course aims to cultivate student’s abilities to choose in an informed way from a toolbox that provides, side by side, modern Western and Islamic methodologies to analyze, understand and engage questions of human social existence.
Comparative Social Sciences
Islamic Civilization: An Alternative Worldview
These Year 1 courses provide a chronological overview and exploration of key core principles and themes in the development of intellectual, cultural, socio-political and economic dimensions in the history of Islamic Civilization, including the birth of the Islamic Disciplines (ʿUlūm). They will start with the birth of Islam until the period just before the Ottoman tanẓīmāt reforms.
One important focus will be the degree to which contemporary Islamic thought will be able to develop a contemporary Islamic worldview that brings together pre-modern and contemporary perspectives in a way that allows us to reach a deeper meaning of what it means to be a “world/universal/open civilization” today. As such, the course will explore the idea of an “Islamic civilization” itself, seeing how it can be rooted in the efforts of pre-modern Muslim intellectual figures but not confined to it.
Comparative Theories and Methods I
The course will provide alternative insights to conventional Western social science methods by highlighting the potential power of the well-established Islamic schools of thought to respond to present questions of social sciences. In this regard, the methods of falsafa, kalām, taṣawwuf, and fiqh will be presented along with a social science and humanities perspective. The course offers multiplexity as an alternative approach to the study of the structure of Islamic sciences. This is because these disciplines, when hierarchically classified, form a cohesive system for a holistic understanding of a multiplex reality. The course aims to cultivate students’ abilities to choose in an informed way from a toolbox that provides, side by side, modern Western and Islamic methodologies to analyze, understand, and engage questions of human social existence.
Comparative Theories and Methods II
The purpose of all social sciences is to answer a fundamental question: what is a human being and why do they do what they are doing in society? This question requires to be systematically answered, hence we need a firm understanding of methodology. The purpose of this course is to uncover the conceptual roots and ontological and epistemological assumptions of major methodological schools in social sciences. While surveying the basic assumptions of major schools, the course will uphold a genetic approach, that is, it will comparatively discuss the origins and theoretical foundations of each school.
Rather than preferring one approach over others, the course aims to illustrate the existence of the wide array of methodological approaches in social sciences. Various approaches emanating from different worldviews and ideologies may sometimes appear in tension with one another. The course aims to bring them in dialogue in a comparative perspective by highlighting their strengths and potentials as well as drawbacks and limitations.
As a core curriculum course it will briefly cover particular major methods and their applications. The detailed examination will be offered by each department in line with their own field-specific priorities. The objective of the course is to create an awareness about the intimate link between fundamental ontological and epistemological assumptions of schools of thought and their methodological preferences, and it will encourage students to recognize and reflect upon variations of these links.
The course will provide alternative insights to conventional Western social science methods by highlighting the potential power of the well-established Islamic schools of thought to respond to present questions of social sciences. In this regard, the methods of falsafa, kalām, taṣawwuf and fiqh will be presented along with with a social science and humanities perspective. They will be presented as paradigms, theories and methods that attempt to answer the core question mentioned above.
In short, the course aims to cultivate student’s abilities to choose in an informed way from a toolbox that provides, side by side, modern Western and Islamic methodologies to analyze, understand and engage questions of human social existence.
Comparative Ethics, Politics and Economics I & II
This course examines broad Islamic perspectives on the ethical, political, and economic domains of society — corresponding to the intellectual, protective and appetitive faculties of the self — and thereby sets forth a comprehensive framework that can shed light on modern ideology in comparative and historical terms.
Part I of the course identifies, from a comparative Islamic perspective, the three most fundamental ideological orientations of self and society: principle, arbitrarism and immanentism. In the ethical domain, this perspective situates the various modern ethical philosophies – alongside their ancient Epicurean, Stoic and Platonic precursors – in relation to an account of the multiplex degrees of the Good in Islamic ethics. In the political domain, it offers a resolution, in Islam’s “principial liberality,” to the modern bipolarity between arbitrarist liberalism and immanentist authoritarianism. In the economic domain, in contradistinction to the injustices intrinsic to the modern economics of arbitrarist wants, economic life in Islam is an eminently moral domain of earning and spending – where earning actualizes dīn in relation to the Creator and spending actualizes akhlāq in relation to creation.
Part II of the course examines the determining phases of the socio-intellectual history of the emergence of modernity, from medieval Christendom, to the age of Absolutism, to Modernity. The transitions in this dynamic are understood as steps in the total inversion of the ethical, political and economic order of society. The immanentist ideology that came to dominate Christendom in the late Middle Ages created fault lines of conflict between priests and princes from which emerged the age of Absolutism, supported by the idea of a “divine right of kings” and the more radical idea of “reason of state.” With Church authority subsumed by political power, forces were released through which the economic domain came to dominate political power and rise to the apex of the social order, thus completing the modern hierarchical inversion. Central to the expansion of this new order around the world was a triad which was first actualized in Britain following the “Glorious Revolution” of 1688: the economic dominance of politics, a debt-based monetary and financial system, and military and economic supremacy.
The Birth of the Modern World
This Year 2 course gives students a broad overview of the development of the modern world from the Western Middle Ages when the West was still traditional through the radical transformations of the Renaissance and the Enlightenment until the early 21th century. The students will gradually become acquainted with the cognitive shifts and philosophical, social, cultural, political, and economic transformations that gave birth to the modern world.
We will look at key figures and currents that brought an end to the traditional worldview and gave birth to the modern worldview. Chronologically, the course will overlap with the last few centuries covered in a previous course on Islamic Civilization but within the Western timeline. Towards the end of the Western timeline, the course will shift back to cover the post-traditional or early modernization period in the Islamic world in the early to mid-19th century.
Self, Society & Politics
The conceptual key to this course will be the important distinction between ‘spiritual authority’ and ‘temporal power.’ These terms will be explained and developed into a framework through which students can then understand and analyse the relationship between moral (religious/spiritual) authority and worldly human institutions that are necessary for the realisation of a moral order on earth. Students will take a journey through Islamic history and select texts, looking at how the relation between spiritual authority and temporal power was negotiated starting with the exemplary model of the Prophet ﷺ, through the paradigmatic four rightly guided caliphs to the Umayyad, Abbassid, and finally the Ottoman example.
The course will then look at how the modern nation-state was introduced into the Muslim world and the consequences it has had on Muslims societies and forms of governance. It will take a close look at what it means for a community to organize itself within a nation-state, the political, moral, and ethical implications for agency and subjectivity. The course will end with an exploration of ways in which pre-modern Islam can address and heal some of the intractable ethical and moral problems created by the modern nation-state and whether or not some pre-modern Islamic forms of governance and moral order are retrievable today.
Comparative Psychology in Light of the Islamic Science of the Soul
This course provides a survey of the Islamic intellectual heritage as it pertains to the subject matter of psychology. The focus of the course will be to provide a familiarity with the classical Islamic scholarly literature drawing directly from its primary sources. This will allow students to have an unfiltered exposure to the style of writings found across different Islamic scholarly disciplines and to become well acquainted with the Islamic scholarly tradition through the words of its authorities directly. The primary sources discussed in this course will largely be drawn from the following classical fields: Ṭibb, Falsafah, Taṣawwuf, Kalām and Fiqh. The style of the course will be one that combines both lecture and reading directly from the original text with the instructor’s commentary.
Additionally, classroom discussions and critical thinking exercises will be included. During the course of the classroom readings, there will be a continuous comparative analysis between these classical Islamic texts and modern psychology. A focus on how rich Islamic scholarly tradition can enhance and enrich modern discourses of psychology is explored. The instructor’s commentary and classroom discussions will pivot around the convergence and divergence between them as well as encouraging critical thinking for how to potentially synthesize or sift through the various parts of these disparate bodies of knowledge.
The History & Philosophy of Science
The conceptual key of this course involves a contrast between two different notions of reason. The course lessons will show, in a comparative context, the broader scope of intellect (ʿaql) and the reductionist nature of rationalism and positivism. It will start by showing the complex nature of reality as a hierarchy of levels (traditional metaphysics), then move on to a detailed discussion of how materialism’s reduction of the levels of reality to just the physical-material plane is illogical and irrational (modern naturalism). It will also show how positivism or empirical reasoning is an inadequate tool for appreciating levels of reality beyond the physical and modes of knowledge beyond the purely rational.
The course will then introduce students to a pre-modern notion of ʿaql that is a lot more expansive. Several lessons will also introduce students to the contemporary debates in the philosophy of science.
Sacred Art, Architecture & Aesthetics
This course’s conceptual key focuses on the distinction between objective beauty and subjective beauty. It develops the argument that most cultures in human history distinguished between two types of beauty: objective and subjective. The former represented by the objective beauty of nature, which held to be universally true while the latter refers to a type of beauty determined by cultural preferences, social distinctions, and personal idiosyncrasies. Through detailed arguments and visual examples (from Christian, Islamic, and World Art), it shows how most cultures saw the emulation of nature as the ideal for art given that nature was fashioned or created by the Supreme Being Who perfected it and so nature alone was worthy of emulation for human art. This explains why so much of traditional art is universally recognized as beautiful.
However, from the European Renaissance onwards, a shift occurred away from objective beauty towards an increasing reliance on subjective criteria for beauty until Romanticism and the 19th century when subjective experiences of what is true and beautiful dominated shifting European aesthetics away from what is objectively true and beautiful to what is subjectively true and beautiful. This gave birth to the artist as ‘genius,’ i.e. as someone possessed of a unique in-born talent who did not conform to the socially acceptable standards of truth and beauty but rather explored the darker realms of one’s interiority or subconscious. This birth of subjectivity has had grave consequences for epistemology, philosophy, ethics, truth, and art.
With colonialism and globalization this has become a universal phenomenon. Its impact on traditional Islamic art, architecture, and urbanism has been catastrophic. This will be explored giving examples from the Islamic world. We will also explore contemporary postmodern art in light of traditional principles of sacred art showing how postmodern art can only produce ugliness because it is no longer anchored in the transcendent dimension of the spirit but rather in the very personal dimension of subjective experience and expression.
Comparative Bio-Ethics
This seminar aims to provide an Islamic perspective on contemporary bio-ethical problems within a fiqh-based worldview, and to give an accurate methodology and interpretative skills in approaching bio-ethical issues. This course will bridge the field of medicine and fiqh, to produce solutions for contemporary problems from within an Islamic framework. The seminar will first introduce students to bio-ethics, its theoretical background, and practical problems, such as organ transplantation, abortion, genetic intervention, euthanasia, and stem cell research. In addition, students will have the knowledge to conduct interdisciplinary research, study and compare the literature on bio-ethics from Islamic and contemporary scientific perspectives.
Comparative Philosophy and Practice of Education
This course provides an introductory exploration of educational philosophies, pedagogies and practices arising from the Islamic intellectual heritage. Through reference to classical texts from both traditions, this course will enable students to critically evaluate and develop a nuanced understanding of the differences and similarities between ‘western’ and Islamic philosophies of education. The work of key contemporary Islamic educational theorists will also be employed to engage in comparative deliberations.
This course will build on the ‘Comparative Psychology’ and ‘Comparative History and Philosophy of Science’ courses to consider Islamic conceptualizations of human development and how these relate to the Islamic concepts of tarbiyah, taʿlīm, taʾdīb and tazkiyah. Conceptualisations of education rooted in these terms will be used to engage in critical evaluation of contemporary Muslim educational practice. Illustrative case studies of contemporary Muslim educational institutions, community projects and innovative models will help students appreciate the practical implications of Islamic educational theory.